Until Dawn - PS4 Trophies List A Symphony of Horror Trophies: You collected all Gold, Silver and Bronze trophies in Until Dawn Fatal Grudge: Chris chose to shoot Ashley The Exorcism of Emily: Mike shot Emily Ashley Snaps: Ashley snapped and let Chris die You Let The Wrong One In!: Ashley or Chris opened the trap door and let the monster in Let eM In: Mike allowed Emily to stay in the basement Instant Inferno: Sam immediately flicked the switch to set the lodge ablaze The Tale of The Two Sisters: The group found all the clues from the Twins Clueline The Fateful Descent: The group found all the clues from the 1952 Clueline You Opened Their Eyes: The group found all the clues from the Mystery Man Clueline Four Daughters Of Darkness: All of the girls survived until dawn They All Live: All eight friends survived until dawn This Is THE End: Nobody survived until dawn Don't Scare Jessica To Death: Jessica survived her night of terror The Skilful Wolf Man: Mike kept the wolf alive throughout the Sanatorium Scream Too!: Mike cut off his fingers to free himself from the bear trap The Psycho Path: Sam or Ashley attacked the psycho with a weapon The Quicker Man: All the boys escaped death Night of the Totem Hunter: The group found all the totems on the mountain