Youtube Thumbnail - Which one

As per usual Sunday's are boring, so I just hopped on Photoshop and started messing around with it and came up with this. One has a rainbow and the other doesn't. Which one is better. I would also I like some feedback and criticism.​

​

Thanks​

​

#1​

Spoiler

​

​

​

​

​

​

#2​

Spoiler

 

I do like #1.

This looks neat and the colouring is a perfect match for everything, lovely work

 

#1 everything blends well
In #2 the rainbow throws everything off ^_^

 

Again #1, It wouldn't hurt for you to try color corrections, they will blend your colors in well and hopefully make it stand out more, but nice job

 

I like the text clean up you did in the second image, it looks really nice. The rest im not much a fan of.

 

The first one looks really good